Without evidence of benefit, an intervention should not be presumed to be beneficial or safe.

- Rogue Medic

Where is the evidence that Quiet and Slow are NOT Jinxes?

In medicine, there are a lot of superstitious people. Any occupation that involves intermittent rewards[1] is going to produce magical thinking[2] in some people. This is true in medicine, sports, gambling, speculation/investment, . . . .

If we do not understand what we are doing, we try to come up with explanations. However, the people least likely to come up with accurate explanations are those who do not understand. If we ask the Insane Clown Posse how magnets work, we get a foolish answer. Magnets are magic to them. Magnets do not work by magic, even though we cannot directly see them working and in spite of the similarity in spelling.[3]

 

Speak of the devil and he’ll appear.
 

Speak of the devil. The devil does not appear.

Say Slow, or Quiet, when it is slower than usual.

Does that cause some supernatural creature to make a frequent flier to call for the same thing he normally calls for, or make some little old lady fall, or make some guy have a heart attack, or make some child drown?

Really?

Have you tried using this power for good?

Say Raise.

Image credit.

It didn’t work?

It works for some people –

Deepak Chopra – one of the highest paid entertainers in the US.

Words do not have magic power, but people do have superstitions.

We become defensive of our childish beliefs and demand proof that they do not work. If I tell you that I can fly, due to some magical power, should anyone believe me?

Should I insist that people believe me, rather than ridicule my claim, unless they can prove that I cannot fly?

Of course not.

Does it matter if I am a four year old or a forty-four year old?

Yes. Magical thinking is expected from a four year old. This is a part of childhood development.

Magical thinking is something we are supposed to grow out of as we mature. Maturity appears to elude some of us for decades.

How can any of us defend this?

When we are unbiased in our use of evidence, we keep ourselves from self-deception.

When we primarily look for ways to defend our biases, we deceive ourselves.

Science is a way of trying not to fool yourself. The first principle is that you must not fool yourself, and you are the easiest person to fool. – Richard Feynman.

We can continue to fool ourselves, which is easy, or we can think for ourselves.

Footnotes:

[1] Schedules of reinforcement
Wikipedia
Reinforcement
Article

[2] Magical thinking
Wikipedia
Article

[3] Magnets
Wikipedia
Article

.

Comments

  1. The same thing could be said about god.

  2. Or you could just have fun with it and not be a douche

    • Bullets,

      Or you could just have fun with it and not be a douche

      I think this kind of belief is just one of the reasons it is so difficult to get rid of traditional harmful practices.

      I want people to understand why they are giving a drug, rather than just blindly following a chest pain chant, or an would that be an infarction incantation?

      All drugs have side effects and we need to understand them better – if our intent is to not harm patients.

      Maybe this kind of superstition explains why it is so difficult to get rid of our backboard ritual used to treat dents on a vehicle.

      A douche cleans – although the medical evidence for the product commonly referred to in the US does not appear to exist. 😉

      Clean is not bad.

      .

  3. It is also possible that those who don’t say “quiet” and “slow” don’t seriously believe they are jinx words, and are simply following a tradition as opposed to believing a superstition. In all seriousness, how many of the people who wear their “lucky jersey” on NFL game day really think that has anything to do with the outcome of the game? Does anyone actually believe in “the gods of EMS” as real sadistic beings? Or is it having fun with a “superstition” and tradition?

    Besides, you’ve got the logic backwards. Using the logic of avoiding the words “quiet” and “slow”, if you say the word “raise”, you’ll get either a pay cut or layoffs. 🙂

  4. A little common sense goes a long way, folks. And having a sense of humor helps as well, especially in our line of work. When people use the words “quiet” or “slow” in the context of wishing us either to have a slow (or a busy) shift, I have always found that they really are hoping we have a good shift. It’s a gallows-humoresque way of doing this, but this is precisely how it is intended. Besides, we all know that we have no control over what happens on any given tour we work no matter what is said to us.

    Not that you need it, amice, but I really think you need to be cut some slack on this one.

  5. i’m not SUPERstitious. just a little stitious.